Pleas against Balaguer’s superplatonism

Matías Alejandro Guirado

Abstract


Mark Balaguer has developed a quirky brand of mathematical plat onism – called ‘full-blooded platonism’ or ‘FBP’ – in order to solve Benacerraf’s problem about the inaccessibility of abstract entities. According to FBP, every mathematical object that can consistently be characterized thereby exists, although contingently so. In this paper I would like to show that ontological plenitude and modal contingency cannot converge into a philosophically respectable theory of mathematical objects. To achieve this, I argue that FBP does not cover some basic factors of epistemic reliability and that it involves a criterion of plenitude both mathematically and metaphysically implausible.

Keywords: Balaguer, Benacerraf, consistency, contingency, superplatonism.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.4013/fsu.2016.171.05



ISSN: 1984-8234 - Best viewed in Mozilla Firefox

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License [Updated on September 23, 2016].

São Leopoldo, RS. Av. Unisinos, 950. Bairro Cristo Rei, CEP: 93.022-750. Atendimento Unisinos +55 (51) 3591 1122 Ext.: 3219




SCImago Journal & Country RankCrossref Member Badge Crossref Similarity Check logo