The Brumadinho Dam Rupture Disaster, Brazil 2019: Analysis of the Narratives about a Disaster from the Perspective of Disaster Law

Delton Winter Carvalho

Resumo


Tailings dam failures with catastrophic consequences are, unfortunately, nothing new in our country. And yet, Disaster Law, a branch of legal practice that highlights the role of the juridical system in reducing the underlying vulnerabilities of these events, is still not widely known. Law plays a central role in the management of catastrophic events. A disaster is the result of social and physical vulnerabilities. In disasters caused by economic activities (anthropogenic or technological disasters), there is an added emphasis on technological vulnerability as a key to identify asymmetries and failures in the flow of information fundamental for the occurrence of the disaster. Based on these premises and on a narrative reconstruction methodology, this article aims to clarify the role of law in events such as this, in order to learn from destructive cycles and prevent new ones.

 


Texto completo:

PDF (English)

Referências


BINDER, D. 2002. Emergency Action Plans: A Legal and Practical Blueprint ‘Failing to Plan is Planning to Fail. University of Pittsburgh Law Review, 63:791-814.

BRANCO, M.; PONSO, F. 2017. Maior desastre ambiental do Brasil, deixou 19 mortos. O Globo. Available at http://acervo.oglobo.globo.com/em-destaque/maior-desastre-ambiental-do-brasil-tragedia-de-mariana-deixou-19-mortos-20208009. Accessed on: 07.23.2018.

BRASIL. 2010a. Federal Decree n. 7.257, 08/04/2010. Available at http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_Ato2007-2010/2010/Decreto/D7257.htm. Accessed on 02.08.2019.

BRASIL.2012b. Federal Law n. 12.608, 04/10/2012. Available at http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_Ato2011-2014/2012/Lei/L12608.htm. Accessed on 02.08.2019.

BRASIL. 2010c. Federal Law n. 12.334, 09/20/2010. Available at http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_Ato2007-2010/2010/Lei/L12334.htm. Accessed on 02.08.2019.

CARVALHO, D. W. de. 2015a. Desastres Ambientais e sua Regulação Jurídica: deveres de prevenção, resposta e compensação ambiental. São Paulo, Revista dos Tribunais, 190 p.

CARVALHO, D. W. de. 2017b. Gestão Jurídica dos Riscos Ambientais. Gestão Jurídica Ambiental. São Paulo, Revista dos Tribunais, p. 150-220.

CARVALHO, D. W. de. 2019c. The Ore Tailings Dam Rupture Disaster in Mariana, Brazil 2015: What We Have to Learn from Anthropogenic Disasters. Natural Resources Journal. 59(2):281-300.

CARVALHO, D. W. de; DAMACENA, F. D. L. 2013. Direito dos Desastres. Porto Alegre, Livraria do Advogado, 152 p.

DOUGLAS, L.; SARAT, A.; UMPHREY, M. M. 2007. A jurisprudence of catastrophe: an introduction. In: L. Douglas, A. Sarat, M. M. Umphrey, Law and catastrophe. Stanford, Stanford University Press, 1-17 pp.

FARBER, D. 2009a. Tort law in the era of climate change, Katrina, and 9/11: exploring liability for extraordinary risks. Valparaíso University Law Review, 43:1-126.

FARBER, D. 2012b. Disaster Law and Emerging Issues in Brazil. Revista de estudos constitucionais, hermenêutica e teoria do direito (RECHTD), 4(1):2-15. Doi: 10.4013/rechtd.2012.41.01

FARBER, D.; CHEN, J.; VERCHICK, R. M.; SUN, L. G. 2010. Disaster law and policy. New York, Aspen Publishers, 465 p.

IBAMA. Available at http://www.ibama.gov.br/noticias/730-2019/1881-rompimento-de-barragem-da-vale-em-brumadinho-mg-destruiu-269-84-hectares. Accessed on 02.08.2019.

ICOLD/UNEP. 2001. Tailings Dams, Risk of Dangerous Occurrences: Lessons learnt from practical experiences. Bulletin 121. Paris, Commission Internationale des Grands Barrages, 144 p. Available at http://www.unep.fr/shared/publications/pdf/2891-TailingsDams.pdf. Accessed on 10.30.2019.

JASSANOF, S. (ed.). 1994. Learning from disaster: risk management after Bhopal. Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press, 312 p.

KNIGHT, F. 1921. Structures and Methods for Meeting Uncertainty. In: F. Knight, Risk, uncertainty and profit. Boston, Hart, Schaffner & Marx; Houghton Mifflin Co., Chapter VII, 243-273 pp.

PHILLIPS, D. 2016. Samarco dam collapse: one year on from Brazil`s worst environmental disaster. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2016/oct/15/samarco-dam-collapse-brazil-worst-environmental-disaster-bhp-billiton-vale-mining. Accessed on 07.23.2018.

RODRIGUES, L. 2019. Brumadinho: o que se sabe até agora sobre a tragédia. Agência Brasil. Available at http://agenciabrasil.ebc.com.br/geral/noticia/2019-02/brumadinho-o-que-se-sabe-ate-agora-sobre-tragedia. Accessed on 11.02.2019.

ROSSI, A. 2019a. Tragédia em Brumadinho: Vale diz que sirenes não foram acionadas por 'velocidade' do deslizamento. BBC News – Brasil. Available at https://www.bbc.com /portuguese/brasil-47063312. Accessed on 02.11.2019.

ROSSI, A. 2019b. Tragédia em Brumadinho: a funcionária da Vale que alertou sobre o desastre pelo rádio e fugiu de ré em caminhão com 90 toneladas. BBC News – Brasil. Available at https://www.bbc.com/portuguese/brasil-47138258. Accessed on 10.10.2019.

SACONI, J. P.; VENTURA, M. 2019. Barragem de Brumadinho tinha baixo risco de acidente, mas alto potencial de danos. O Globo Brasil. Available at https://oglobo.globo.com/brasil/barragem-de-brumadinho-tinha-baixo-risco-de-acidente-mas-alto-potencial-de-danos-23401587. Accessed on: 02.09.2019.

SARAT, A.; LEZAUN, J. (Ed.). 2009. Catastrophe: law, politics, and the humanitarian impulse. Amherst, University of Massachusetts, 240 p.

SOUTO, I. 2019. Número de mortos em Brumadinho chega a 165. Estado de Minas. Available at https://www.em.com.br/app/noticia/gerais/2019/02/10/interna_gerais,1029434/numero-de-mortos-em-brumadinho-chega-a-165.shtml. Accessed on 02.07.2019.

STERLING, A.; GEE, D. 2002. Science, precaution and practice. Public Health Reports, Association of Schools of Public Heath, 117:521-533.

STOCHERO, T. 2019. Vale anuncia mais duas doações, de R$ 50 mil e R$ 15 mil, a atingidos pela lama na tragédia em Brumadinho. G1 – Minas Gerais. Available at https://g1.globo.com/mg/minas-gerais/noticia/2019/02/01/vale-anuncia-mais-duas-doacoes-de-r-50-mil-e-r-15-mil-a-atingidos-pela-lama-na-tragedia-em-brumadinho.ghtml. Accessed on 11.02.2019.

SUGERMAN, S. D. 2006. Roles of government in compensating disaster victims. Issues in Legal Scholarship. The Berkeley Electronic Press. Manuscript 1093:1-33.

SUNSTEIN, C. 2005. Irreversible and Catastrophic. Public Law and Legal Theory Working Papers. University of Chicago Law School, 88:01-67.

TOLEDO, A.; RIBEIRO, J. C. J.; THOMÉ, R. 2016. Acidentes com Barragens de Rejeitos de Mineração e o Princípio da Prevenção: de Trento (Itália) a Mariana (Brasil). Rio de Janeiro, Lumen Juris, 176 p.

VERCHICK, R. M. 2019a. (In)justiça dos desastres: a geografia da capacidade humana. In: D. Farber, D. W. de Carvalho (org.). Estudos Aprofundados em Direito dos Desastres: interfaces comparadas. Curitiba, Appris/Prismas, 59-106 pp.

VERCHICK, R. M. 2010b. Facing Catastrophe: Environmental Action for a Post-Katrina World. Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 322 p.

VERCHICK, R. M. 2012c. Disaster Justice: The Geography of Human Capability. Duke Environmental Law & Policy Forum, 23:23-71.

WORLD MINE TAILINGS FAILURES. 2020a. Remembering Aznalcóllar April 25, 1998. Available at https://worldminetailingsfailures.org. Accessed on 02.08.2019.

WORLD MINE TAILINGS FAILURES. 2020b. Available at https://worldminetailingsfailures.org. Accessed on 02.08.2019.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.4013/rechtd.2020.122.04



ISSN: 2175-2168 - Melhor visualizado no Mozilla Firefox

Licença Creative Commons
Este trabalho está licenciado sob uma Licença Creative Commons Attribution 3.0

São Leopoldo, RS. Av. Unisinos, 950. Bairro Cristo Rei, CEP: 93.022-000. Atendimento Unisinos +55 (51) 3591 1122

Projeto gráfico: Jully Rodrigues



SCImago Journal & Country RankCrossref Member Badge Crossref Similarity Check logo